| This exercise is to
help you decide whether you are properly classifying a worker as an independent
contractor under IRS guidelines used to determine worker status.
While an independent contractor has
some definite advantages, the advantages could be offset by huge liabilities
should the IRS, or state agencies, later determine that your worker was
not, in fact, properly designated as an independent contractor.
This Independent Contractor Test asks
you the primary questions from to the "control test" used by the IRS.
When in doubt about, it is safest to
classify the worker as an employee. If you have questions, consult the
IRS for their interpretation or an attorney or individual with expertise
in independent contractor classification matters.
DISCLAIMER: This is not a substitute
for legal advice nor to provide legal guidance. It is the responsibility
of employers to obey all applicable federal and state laws that affect
them.
Answer each of the following questions
and then check the results to help you determine a worker’s classification.
(answers
below)
1. Do you provide instructions
to the worker about when, where, and how he or she is to perform the work?
( ) Yes ( ) No
2. Do you provide training to the worker?
( ) Yes ( ) No
3. Are the services provided by the
worker integrated into your business operations?
( ) Yes ( ) No
4. Must the services be rendered personally
by the worker? (
) Yes ( ) No
5. Do you hire, supervise, and pay
assistants to the worker? (
) Yes ( ) No
6. Is there a continuing relationship
between you and the worker? (
) Yes ( ) No
7. Do you set the work hours and schedule?
( ) Yes ( ) No
8. Does the worker devote substantially
full time to your business? (
) Yes ( ) No
9. Is the work performed on your premises?
( ) Yes ( ) No
0. Is the worker required to perform
the services in an order or sequence set by you?
( ) Yes ( ) No
11. Is the worker required to submit
oral or written reports to you? (
) Yes ( ) No
12. Is the worker paid by the hour,
week, or month? ( )
Yes ( ) No
13. Do you have the right to discharge
the worker at will? (
) Yes ( ) No
14. Can the worker terminate his or
her relationship with you any time he or she wishes
without incurring liability to you? (
) Yes ( ) No
15. Do you pay the business or traveling
expenses of the worker? (
) Yes ( ) No
16. Does the worker furnish significant
tools, materials and equipment? (
) Yes ( ) No
17. Does the worker have a significant
investment in facilities? (
) Yes ( ) No
18. Can the worker realize a profit
or loss as a result of his or her services?
( ) Yes ( ) No
19. Does the worker provide services
for more than one firm at a time? (
) Yes ( ) No
20. Does the worker make his or her
services available to the general public?
( ) Yes ( ) No
Explanation of each question.
1. Do you provide instructions
to the worker about when, where, and how he or she is to perform the work?
Compliance
With Instructions
Workers who must comply with another
person’s instructions about when, where, or how to work generally are considered
employees. This applies even if the other person has the right to require
compliance but does not exercise that right.
2. Do you provide training to
the worker?
Training
Requiring that a worker be trained
through such methods as working with an experienced employee, attending
instructional sessions or training courses, or corresponding with the employer,
is indicative of employee status because it shows that the employer controls
the way the work is done or the method that is used. Independent contractors,
on the other hand, normally are not trained by the purchasers of their
services.
3. Are the services provided
by the worker integrated into your business operations?
Integration
Into the Business
The fact that a worker’s services
are so integrated into an employer’s operations that the success or continuation
of the business depends on the performance of the services generally indicates
that the individual is subject to a certain amount of control by the owner
of the business.
4. Must the services be rendered
personally by the worker?
Personal Services
Required
Employee status is suggested if a
worker is required to personally render the services in question, because
such an arrangement indicates that the employer controls the methods used
to accomplish the tasks. By contrast, a worker’s right to substitute another’s
services without the employer’s knowledge suggests the existence of a contractor
relationship.
5. Do you hire, supervise, and
pay assistants to the worker?
Control Over
the Hiring, Supervising, and Paying of Assistants
An employer that hires, supervises,
and pays a worker’s assistants usually is viewed as controlling the work
(and the individual performing the services) in question. On the other
hand, workers who hire, supervise, and pay other workers in situations
where they have agreed to provide the labor needed to attain a certain
result generally are treated as independent contractors.
6. Is there a continuing relationship
between you and the worker?
A Continuing
Relationship
Employees usually are hired for a
continuing, indefinite period. This generally applies even to work or services
performed on an irregular but recurring basis, as well as to part-time,
temporary, and seasonal work. The relationship between an independent contractor
and employer, on the other hand, usually ends when the job is finished.
7. Do you set the work hours
and schedule?
Set Hours
of Work
A requirement that workers adhere
to certain work hours established by the employer generally is viewed as
a factor indicating employer control.
8. Does the worker devote substantially
full time to your business?
A Full-time
Work Requirement
Employee status is suggested if a
worker must work on a substantially full-time basis for the employer since
this indicates that the employer controls the amount of time the individual
spends working and thus essentially restricts the worker’s ability to perform
services for someone else. By contrast, independent contractors typically
are free to work when and for whom they choose.
9. Is the work performed on your
premises?
Working on
the Employer’s Premises
Performance of work on the employer’s
premises may be evidence of employer control, especially if the work could
be done elsewhere. While performance at an off-premises site demonstrates
some freedom from employer control, it does not by itself mean that the
worker is an independent contractor. The importance of the work-on-premises
factor depends on the nature of the service involved and the extent to
which an employer generally world require that employees perform such services
on the employer’s premises. Employer control is suggested when the employer
has the right to compel the worker to travel a designated route, to canvass
a territory within a certain time, or to work at specific places.
10. Is the worker required to
perform the services in an order or sequence set by you?
A Required
Work Order or Sequence
A requirement that a worker perform
work in a certain order or sequence may indicate that the employer controls
or retains the right to control the worker.
11. Is the worker required to
submit oral or written reports to you?
Required Reports
A degree of control is suggested where
a worker is required to submit regular oral or written reports to the employer.
12. Is the worker paid by the
hour, week, or month?
Payment by
the Hour, Week, or Month
Employees generally are paid by the
hour, day, or month, while independent contractors typically are paid by
the job or on a lump-sum or straight commission basis.
13. Do you have the right to
discharge the worker at will?
Employer’s
Discharge Rights
If an employer has the right to discharge
an individual, that worker is viewed as an employee. Independent contractors,
on the other hand, cannot be fired as long as they perform services in
accordance with their contract specifications.
14. Can the worker terminate
his or her relationship with you any time he or she wishes without incurring
liability to you?
Worker’s Termination
Rights
Employees typically can end their
employment relationship at any time without incurring any liability, whereas
independent contractors might be liable for a breach of contract if they
leave without completing their work.
15. Do you pay the business or
traveling expenses of the worker?
Payment of
Business or Travel Expenses
Employer payment of a worker’s business
or work-related travel expenses generally indicates employee status.
16. Does the worker furnish significant
tools, materials and equipment?
Furnishing
of Tools and Materials
An employer-employee relationship
is indicated where an employer supplies a worker with a significant amount
of the tools, materials, or other equipment needed to perform services.
Moreover, in some occupations and industries where it is customary for
individuals to provide their own tools, these workers also may be treated
as employees.
17. Does the worker have a significant
investment in facilities?
Investment
in Facilities
Individuals are likely to be treated
as independent contractors if they have a significant investment in the
facilities they use in the course of performing services (such as an office
rented at fair market value from a third party). IRS stresses that “special
scrutiny is required with respect to certain types of facilities, such
as home offices.”
18. Can the worker realize a
profit or loss as a result of his or her services?
Risks of Profit
or Loss
Independent contractors typically
can invest significant amounts of time or capital in their work without
any guarantee of success (that is they realize a profit or sustain a loss
based on their success in performing the work or service). When workers
are insulated from loss or are restricted in the amount of profit they
can gain, they usually are classified as employees.
19. Does the worker provide services
for more than one firm at a time?
Working For
More Than One Firm
Workers who perform services for a
number of businesses or people at the same time usually are considered
independent contractors. However, a worker who performs services for more
than one person may be an employee of each of the persons, especially where
such persons are part of the same service arrangement.
20. Does the worker make his
or her services available to the general public?
Worker’s Availability
to the General Public
Workers who make their services available
to the public on a regular and consistent basis generally are treated as
independent contractors.
|